Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies with Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, Family Size, 14.25 oz

Excellent cookies good taste I've tried the regular and the chewy I prefer the regular but they're both very good especially with some nice cold milk

Opening the bag you get hit with an instant whoosh of chocolate, and the taste matches exactly that, a fudgy chocolate cookie, but with the ST cookie, it has strawberry cream filling and that really makes these what they are. Almost similar to a chocolate covered strawberry. It tastes fairly natural for being in a cookie! Both flavors are very rich, again the chocolate is rich and deep in flavor I compare it to a brownie and the strawberry adds it a nice kick of fruity flavor. Also it has mini chocolate chips! Adds a nice additional texture! I was expecting it to be raspberry beforehand but I will say it does taste like it fits the theme of Stranger Things. The red color pops nicely like the forest in the Upside Down, dark brown like Will Byers' bowl cut- I mean like the dirt separating the 2 worlds. Season 5 color palette and flavor makes sense for the show. Definitely giving the feeling that you're eating a mysterious cookie that even a demogorgon would like so be careful leaving these out or they (me) would eat them all. My pack of cookies came great, fresh, and whole! Very happy for getting these online and would get more again in a bigger pack. And as a cookie enthusiast, I would say out of the lineup they have, this is one of the better ones.

These cookies are slightly crunchier than like a Grandma’s Cookie. But personally I feel like the taste is unbeat by any other cookie than perhaps homemade. They are absolutely stuffed with chocolate and absolutely fantastic. I bought them once and now I have to have a stash in my closet for when I need a cookie while reading. I highly recommend these! Please note, they can get a little broken when you’re pulling them out of the package. I frequently grab a whole cookie and end up with only a half because the bottom stays in the packaging. But that is fine with me and typically only happens with the first one in every row because they are packed tightly to prevent them breaking in transport. I’m sure it is partially me too because if you slow down and pull straight up it typically doesn’t happen and it typically only happens to me when I try to remove multiple cookies from the unstaffed row at the same time.

🌟🌟🌟🌟☆ 4 out of 5 stars These are seriously tasty cookies. The texture is perfectly soft and chewy, and the combo of chocolate chips with chunks of Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups is rich, indulgent, and totally satisfying. For a packaged cookie, they’re hard to beat. I grab the family-size pack when it’s on sale (around $4) and it makes for an easy treat to share—or keep for myself over a few days. That said, I do want to note a few concerns with the ingredients. These cookies contain high fructose corn syrup, palm oil, artificial flavors, hydrogenated vegetable oils, and TBHQ as a preservative. While none of these are uncommon in processed snacks, they’re worth mentioning if you’re trying to avoid overly processed or synthetic ingredients. I also try to be mindful of additives like TBHQ and trans fats for long-term health, especially since I’m already dealing with health issues. So, while I really enjoy the flavor and texture, I treat these as an occasional indulgence rather than an everyday snack. If you’re sensitive to preservatives or avoiding certain oils and sweeteners, just read the label first. Still, if you’re after a soft, sweet, peanut-buttery cookie that hits all the nostalgic notes, this is a solid pick—just enjoy it in moderation.

BUY IT! You know what, buy 2 boxes because you’re going to gobble one box up so quick! If you like cookie butter, you’re going to LOVE these cookies. They’re even better with a glass of milk!

Let's just say, I should have ordered more! I had to tell everyone they were gross so I could eat them all!!

I am a big fan of Reese's candies, so I wanted to give these a shot. Was hoping they would be great, but I was unfortunately disappointed. They tasted decent, but nothing to write home about. The cookies were smaller in size than I expected and were a bit too sweet. Plus, some of the cookies were broken apart due to shipping. Honestly, I probably won't purchase these again.

I thought that these would taste heavily like chemicals, or just be flat out terrible, but they are respectable enough and are more pleasant than I expected, they do have a flavor that is slightly reminiscent of cookie butter, but honestly, they are a bit lacking in that department, they mostly remind me of spiced cookies, sorta gingerbreadesk, but I’d buy them again if I came across them cause they are pretty addictive

👍

Good but handling is bad. Half of the cookies came were squashed.