Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer Eyeliner, Highly Pigmented, Long-Wearing, Built-In Smudger, 230, Deep Ocean, 0.01oz

I absolutely love this eyeliner! This shade, EARL GRAY, is my go-to and I use it 9 out of 10 times. It’s the perfect pigment for me as I rarely wear black eye makeup but this is dark enough to give me enough definition and the texture glides on easily without snagging/pulling the delicate skin around my eyes. I love that it is a twist turn and that I don’t have to sharpen/shave the pencil down for more product. The color stays on for quite some time, all day for me, but if I’m going out in the evening I definitely need to reapply for a fresh look. I don’t use any kind of primer or setting spray so I’m sure it would last longer for those who do. At the end of my day it’s very easy to wipe this off and doesn’t give me raccoon eyes in the morning if I accidentally sleep with it on. Great quality and value for low maintenance, low cost, eye color!

Nice bold color last longer than many other eyeliner. Doesn't smear all over the place. By far my favorite choice.

Earl Grey is the perfect color. Easy to apply, no pulling or drag. Stays on all day.

This has been my go to eyeliner for years. I wear the rich brown shade and it's very pretty paired with my pale skin and strawberry blond hair. It applies easily and smoothly but does smudge easily. I do have to touch up on days where my eyes water due to allergies. If you are someone who has frequent eye watering issues due to allergies, contacts, or from bursting into tears when it's time to clock in for work, then you may be disappointed in this eyeliner. It is NOT waterproof or smudge proof. But overall, it's still a decent eyeliner. At least for me.

I decided to try the Rimmel London Exaggerate Auto Waterproof Eye Definer in Blackest Black, and I have to say, it was the best decision ever! Right from the first application, the color payoff is fantastic—it’s truly that deep, bold black that I was looking for. It glides on smoothly without any tugging on the eyes, which is a major plus for me. One of my favorite things about this eyeliner is how long it lasts. I wore it for a full day at work, and it stayed put without smudging, even after a long day of meetings and the occasional teary moment from laughing too hard. It's definitely waterproof, which is something I appreciate, especially with the unpredictable weather we have here. The auto twist-up feature is super handy too! No more dull pencil sharpening for me. This double pack is also great—having a backup is always nice! Overall, I highly recommend the Rimmel London Exaggerate Auto Waterproof Eye Definer for anyone looking for a reliable, bold eyeliner that won't budge. It’s been an amazing addition to my makeup routine! I will repurchase this forever!!

Perfect shade and doesn’t run. Easy to use and doesn’t dry out in a day.

This eyeliner is easy to apply, and the pigment is impressively dark. It does last through the day and the smudger is a helpful touch for blending. However, I found that the waterproof claim doesn't fully hold up—after a few hours, there was noticeable smudging, especially in humid weather. Removal requires a bit more effort, and the pencil tip can break easily if too much pressure is used. Overall, it's an okay option for everyday use, but I expected a bit more lasting power and durability for the price.

Really is water proof I have watery eyes and this works amazing I even tested it and it lasted for over 3 days. Is slowly will die down and it's color but it does stay on. Very easy to apply no smudging no broken tips. It looks great. Definitely will be getting more