Bobbi Brown No Smudge Mascara (New Packaging), 01 Black, 0.18 Ounce

I have greasy eyelids. This mascara is great, it truly doesn't smudge. It doesn't make your lashes look longer or anything, it's just plain mascara otherwise. But I am so sick of smudging it's worth it

I like this mascara because my other mascaras tend to clump up after awhile. It really does seem to be no smudge.

For years I put up with mascara that ran whenever my eyes teared up. I finally called a beauty expert and asked how brides made it through their wedding day without black streaks on their faces. I was told about Bobbi Brown mascara and I have used it ever since.

This is the only mascara that is truly smudge proof. It doesn't leave you looking like a raccoon and the end of the day.

This is the best I've found so far, for lasting and not bleeding, but when it's new, I need to be careful not to use too much, or it will leave me with raccoon eyes.. My last shipment never appeared..

I shelled out the cash on this as a last resort. I have small hooded eyes and I have never ever found a mascara that has not smudged until this one. I’ve tried dozens over the course of a decade plus. This one is worth every penny. It goes on well and it stays put, even when I’m sweaty or crying.

I almost hate that this is my holy grail mascara, because it's a bit pricey and definitely has some flaws, but I keep coming back to it time and again because it makes my lashes look so great, is waterproof, smudge-proof, and lasts almost forever once it's on! If anyone has a legit dupe I've tried several and none have lived up to the wear on this bad girl.

It claims to be smudge proof but it smudges a bit and definitely has tiny clumps on lashes. Not a big fan.