ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil, Brown [203], 0.01 oz (Pack of 2)

I like that it is smudge resistant and stays put.

I have been using this Revlon eyeliner for decades is the only one I use when I was younger. I use the black, then the brown-black, now that I am older, I use the brown. I have always been satisfied with it. It stays on a long time and is waterproof. I do not use the sharpener. I just rub the sides of the pencil on a piece of toilet tissue. I have always been satisfied with the performance.

Very good product, I order consistently, however, seems to be more black than brown.

Great eyeliner. Goes on well and doesn’t smudge or bleed during the day.

I broke down & bought this eyeliner out of desperation as the last few I’d purchased, through different companies, did not seem to hold onto their pencil leads more than a few times. I’d roll them up ( or try to!) & find there was nothing there. Of course, after this happened a few times, I thought, “surely this is user error, so I’d be most conscientious about making sure that lead was screwed back into the case, gently, so it wouldn’t fall out. But my lead was, nonetheless, disappearing from the case. Luckily, I have not had that happen with this product. And the staying power & non-smudging components are very good, too. My only complaint would be that the line it draws is a bit thicker than I would like. And that’s not really adjustable. Yes, the smudge feature is ok for that, but I’d still prefer a thinner line, initially. I do like that this will last awhile it appears, and I like being able to buy it in a brown/ black color wave as opposed to just black or brown. Overall, a good purchase & one I’ll buy again. Good price, too.

I have been using this eyeliner for YEARS! I get so many compliments because it stays on even if I’m sweating, working out, swimming. Sometimes it’s still on after I take a shower. If I don’t take it off before bed it looks just as good in the morning. I highly recommend this and you can’t beat the price. Don’t forget there is a tiny sharpener under the bottom of it. It also twists up and down.

Separates lashes and coats them well with two applications. Easy to remove too.

This is my go-to eyeliner. I put it on in the morning and it stays all day, even through sweat and tears! I also appreciate the smudger tip on the other end. There's also no sharpener needed

Really happy with this. A nice dark brown that still doesn't look black. Comfortable to wear and easy to apply. Seems to be actually waterproof since I wore it on my waterline and it stayed for several hours. I thought the smudging tool and sharpener would be a bit gimmicky, but they're actually functional! The sharpener is especially useful since I can use it with my other retractable pencils. I clean both these tools with a cloth and some rubbing alcohol if I use them on another colour of pencil.

Used this for many years , couldn’t find it in my regular shop