Slide On Pencil, Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil - Brown Perfection

Amazing

I can't answer if this is quality as far as how long it will stay on during the day, and hold it's pigment. However, this is the first time I am branching out from high end cosmetics, I heard good things about NYX. I received this and tried it immediately. It was just a pencil (not gel or liquid) so I assumed it would go on dry and tough. WOW WAS I WRONG. This glided like butter, like my high end pencils. I took it a step further and did my eyelid completely, testing it for coverage, how fast the tip wore down, etc....you can MOST DEFINATELY use this as an eyeshadow too, and it took me 2 seconds to cover that much area because it goes on so smoothly! its that smooth. And the point of this pencil was still there completely when i was done....not even a hint of wear down. the color was soooo accurate and beautiful (gunmetal) that I was once again surprised. So i can use this for liner, or shadow. And not spend $20-$30 on colored pencils. Puts Urban Decay, MAC, and Lancome to the test easily in quality. However, how long it will stay on, and rich, is as you know, SUPER IMPORTANT! So, As far as sustainablility, THAT i can not answer yet. But im very very very happy with it! Will update once i have used it all day as far as the sustainability question.

Nice color. I have two different shades of blue. This is one abs both are great.

The pencil itself is fine. The color was not what I expected, so I tossed it. Can't give an honest review since I couldn't use it.

I use this in my lower waterline with NYX CHOCOLATE BROWN on my upper lid. This stays in my waterline all day. It is such a pretty cool grey and doesn’t look too harsh on my mature 46 year old eyes. I tried it on top of my upper lashes because I love the color, but it doesn’t stay there all day like the liquid liner from NYX liquid liner looks too flat and harsh in my waterline so the combo is perfect

Easy to apply , the quality is ok and it does last a good enough of time

Pretty color. I ordered 3 different ones. But none of them will advance when it gets low. You can't sharppen it. And there is more inside because I broke one in half to check. Very disappointing.

I just received my eyeliner. I am disappointed to see that it is a retractable. I was expecting to be able to sharpen it. I do not see anywhere in the description that it is a retractable. I just read some of the reviews, and it sounds like some of the people got retractable, and some of them have pencils that you can sharpen. I will keep it, and try it, but I think you should be able to receive what you ordered, especially when they show a picture of it. So in that sense, I am disappointed.