Cold Steel Scottish Broad Sword

Excellent quality and design. Grip is nice and comfortable. It’s a bit on heavy side. All in all good value. Didn’t like the red so I customized it with my Scottish Clan Keith Tartan colors. And got a shoulder sword frog for it since it’s heavy on the belt, the sword disarm loops on body facing side pushes into torso though, may need to bend it away from body or remove it.

This sword is beautifully made and sturdy, as one expects from Cold Steel. I did remove the annoying tassels and basket liner (I'll replace with a soft green leather half-liner). Also, be aware that "Cold Steel" is stamped on the locket of the scabbard and the inside of the basket, but this doesn't really detract from the sword's overall appearance. The blade came slightly sharp and could easily be made deadly, but I'll dull the blade as I've no intention of cutting anything with this. I am quite pleased with my purchase.

Wonderful quality. Arrived quite sharp out of the box.

A badass sword from a badass culture. This blade is of pretty high quality steel. It's sharp and has held its edge after some playful abuse. The scabbard is very nice as well -- very smooth black leather (or a convincing imitation), with a belt hook. Also, I like that the basket hilt is black -- it's sleek and doesn't get a tarnished or smudgy look unlike the metallic-colored versions. It feels a bit heavier than the genuine pieces I've handled in Scotland, but I guess that's my only complaint. Got mine from Knife Country USA -- fast service, no issues.

Keep it in the workshop to protect the kids from the bears and cougars. It’s a silly way to feel safe in the hills but it’ll do the trick

I probably should give this two stars, but because I'm keeping it, so I'll go with three. This is the 2nd one I've purchased for gifts - to my son, and now my son-in-law. I bought the first one in 2012. It came in an unopened factory shipping box, which contained the carton with the sword. With the first purchase, both cartons were taped and heavily stapled, never opened. The blade was wrapped separate from the scabbard because the blade was covered with cosmolene to protect it from rust. It required cleaning before putting it into the scabbard. The blade was nicely sharpened about halfway along its length. The broadsword I received today was in a single box. The tape had been cut, the lid was not fastened. It had been tampered with. Inside, the blade was in the scabbard, with some cosmolene on it when I removed it. The sharpening job is terrible. It goes halfway up one edge, but almost full length on the other. However, that's not all, it's uneven and dull near the tip. Normally I'd send it back, but as I intend to sharpen both edges full-length anyway, as I did with the first one, I'll clean up both edges, first with a fine flat bastard mill file, very carefully, and finish with stones. I can generally produce a nice, even bevel by frequently looking down the edge in strong light, while sharpening, and being very careful, not too aggressive with the file. All else is OK, but the packaging makes me think that once again Amazon is selling 2nd hand, returned items. They did that a few months ago with a vacuum cleaner. Amazon made it good, but it was a pain. If you're not into customizing your weapons and get something like this, I recommend returning it. As for the sword, the tang is not peened. The pommel is threaded onto the tang, and on close examination isn't aesthetically well-matched to the handle - no transition from a wide, flat washer surface to the smaller handle diameter. It serves its purpose but looks over large. The decorative tassel covers the juncture up. The sword is well-balanced, not overly heavy. There is a central fuller with two, narrower, machine cut grooves paralleling the fuller, not something you see on traditional broadswords. The basket could be a little rounder to give more freedom to the knuckles - it's squared off on the sides, which makes it stable for dancers or for laying on a table, not so good for swinging. However, I won't pretend that I'll ever be in any clan battles, so it's an intellectual exercise. This is not a replica, isn't intended to be. It's a modern version of the scottish basket hilted sword. The bluing and scabbard match the Cold Steel dirk. The scabbard comes with a locket. If you get one of these weapons, you aren't into absolute accuracy. The locket is marked "Cold Steel" and isn't a Jacobite era fixture. However, the locket makes using a baldric (with a slotted scabbard frog) really easy to live with when you're kilted up. When you sit down to some fine haggis (or in my case pizza - that's why my ancestors left Scotland - no mair haggis!) you can easily remove your scabbard from the baldric without removing the baldric. Beware spending a lot of money on piper's crossbelts. They work OK with flat swords, but the frog doesn't extend far enough out from the baldric to accommodate a basket hilt. There is an outfit that makes a very serviceable, Revolutionary War era baldric for re-enactors. It works vey nicely with this broadsword.

Excellent sword, has a nice edge on it but some extra honing would really put a fine one on it. The tassel looks nice but is a bit inconvenient and I will probably remove it. Very happy with the purchase.

Cold Steel has fabulous product, well tested & crafted extremely well. Balance is great! All their blades are ready to use.

Sehr gut und aufwendig verarbeitet. Die Klinge ist absolut gerade, scharf geschliffen und sehr gut poliert. Sehr dekorativ an der Wand, aber auch für praktische Anwendungen gut geeignet.

Very interesting and good quality sword. I wouldn't consider this a replica sword because with a bit of honing it would very easily be a very serious weapon. The steel is good quality, the scabbard is very nicely done if a little plain, and I am more than happy with my purchase.

It is great and it made a great gift

Decent representation of a basket hilted broadsword. A tad heavy but not unmanageable as Cold Steel does overbuild their blades for durability and cutting. Sheath is "meh" but serviceable. Not a fan of the blueing but its growing on me over time. Basket is not over large which is nice. Fits my hand ok but better with a leather fencers glove....the ray skin wrap feels a little abrasive. Overall quite happy with the sword.

Cheaply made sheath