NYX Mechanical Lip Pencil, Black Lips

this is such a great product.

Received with it unsealed and saw that the tip was uneven and the sides had residue, meaning it was used and sent to me.

Goes on so smoothly and has great coverage.

This was my first ever black lip liner, so I will say it is pretty beginner friendly. It's a bit soft so it does break if you're not careful, but it's as not sticky as some lip liners I've tried. I also like how long the lip liner is so I can hold it steadier. It's very creamy but doesn't budge as easily as I have expected from such a creamy formula.

I'm a bit disappointed by this liner. I got the black shade to wear under a Nyx black lipstick, and after a few hours of wear the lipstick was only rubbing off where the liner was applied under it. It was also already broken when I received it, so whenever I open it the stick of liner it's usually stuck to the lid so I have to be sure and carefully shove it back down into the stick so it doesn't break/fall out completely. On the plus side the color is very pigmented and it feels very smooth when applying it, it just seems to have some longevity issues.