2 in 1 Black and Brown Gel Eyeliner Set Water Proof Smudge Proof, Last for All Day Long, Work Great with Eyebrow, 2 Pieces Eye Makeup Brushes Included

I’m honestly really impressed with this eyeliner set. The black is super rich and perfect for a bold wing, while the brown gives a softer everyday look. The gel formula goes on really smooth and doesn’t tug on my eyelids like some other liners I’ve tried. What I love most is how long it lasts. I wore it for a full workday and even after running errands in the evening it still looked great—no smudging or fading. It’s also actually waterproof, which is rare because a lot of liners claim that but don’t hold up. If you like having both a dramatic and natural option in one set, this is definitely worth it. I’ve been reaching for it almost every day.

Love it! Could not imagine that this type of eyeliner is so easy to apply! It is a great option (2 colors together) for ladies with light skin and medium blond hair, like I am. I mix brown and black colors by dipping the brush in black than in brown, wipe a little on the side of my hand, mix the colors and get a softer color - perfect soft black. The brushes work very well, I like especially the angled one. This brush allows me to make a very soft, delicate line, very close to the lashes. It takes about 15 minutes to dry, which is a perfect time for someone not very experienced to get the eyeliner exactly right on both eyes... I have used a pencil style eyeliner for more than 25 years and was very skeptical of the gel style eyeliner. I thought it will be a harsh look and hard to apply. To my big surprise it is very gentle, even more gentle than a pencil and stays on much better, especially in summer time. I had a PRK eye surgery after which my eyes became very sensitive and this eyeliner does not irritate my eye lids. The only advise-do not use a heavy eye cream, just a gel or a lotion type eye cream or it will effect this eyeliner staying power. The easiest way to remove this eyeliner is oil based remover or Vaseline, Aquaphor, Abilene moisturizing cleanser. The price is also great.

I couldn’t wait to wear it !!!! Great product , it does bleed a lil but for the price it’s very nice.

Wow, this is great stuff! I wish I had known about it years ago before damaging my eyelids with those pencils, etc. This eyeliner is so smooth & easy to apply. Highly pigmented, the black is super black! Once dry it is waterproof! The fist time I used it, I spent the day in the rain & expected to look like a raccoon when I got home. Nope, didn't happen. This stuff stayed put all day. It comes off easily with eye makeup remover. I hope the manufacturer stays in business because I will be purchasing this product from now on. Incredible value. The only thing I would add would be to improve the brushes. Mine broke as I was taking it out of the box. I can handle it, I have superglue. & this product is so awesome that I couldn't take away a star. Highly recommend! Buy it!

I really liked this eyeliner at first, but then I didn’t. But first the good. It is highly pigmented, I love that it’s smudge proof and doesn’t transfer onto hooded eyelids or collects in the corners of my eyes. If you have never used an eyeliner brush, it may require some practice, but it glides on nice, and smooth. Now the not so good. On June 21, we lost my little brother (42 YOA) to cirrhosis of the liver. Yesterday, as I was going through his clothing to donate to the veterans Hospital, I ended up finding his favorite shirt. As I grabbed the shirt and started to hug it, I noticed it smelt like him and I completely lost it. I just sat there ugly crying and hugging his shirt. After a few minutes, I decided it was too much and that I wasn’t ready to give his things away yet, so I put his clothing away. I go to the bathroom to blow my nose and clean my face up a little. I noticed I had black streaks of eyeliner all over my face and transfer marks on my top eyelids. Now granite most eyeliner and mascara will run with a good cry. However, waterproof makeup isn’t supposed to run that bad. I can say that with 100% confidence as I had on a different brand of waterproof gel eyeliner the day of his memorial service where I cried even longer and harder without any black streaks on my face. All in all it’s an OK product but it isn’t as waterproof as others and I do not recommend wearing it if you’re an emotional wreck or going to the pool.

There is so much to like about these two precious little jars of eye joy: PROS: 1) PRICE: Typically the suggestion that "you get what you pay" is true, but in this case the value is extraordinary. For under $6, my expectations were super low, but I figured I'd try them--not much to lose, right? They are now among my favs and far better than the price would indicate. 2) MULTI-MULTI PURPOSE: Two colors, black & brown. Two uses, eyeliner & brows. Two brushes. 3) COLOR: I haven't found a brown eyeliner that works well for me, and this one does for a bit subtler effect when I don't want the more dramatic black. 4) EASY ON & STAYS ON: In the short video I made applying this, keep in mind I'm holding a camera with one hand, holding the brush with the other (which is none too steady) & applying to aging, wrinkly eyelids--and this still goes on smoothly. Quite the feat. The gel stays liquid for just the right amount of time to flow on, then it dries just right so it doesn't smudge and it doesn't flake. CONS: 1) A few reviewers have complained that the brushes are not top-notch. Really? The brushes work just fine. They are not The Best Ever, but they do the job. For under $6, are you really expecting two jars of exceptional product and two brushes that merit a designer label? As you might guess, overall, I'm blown away by this product and the exceptional value it offers.

I normally don't write reviews but this eyeliner is the worst! It has very little pigment, however it does have some staying power. Save your money do not buy!

Such a amazing product found on Amazon waterproof very reasonable

Good for aging eyes s doesn't seem to smudge once applied, but can be blended

The eyeliner was good quality and stays on the waterline, the brushes included are handy. Unfortunately I only recieved one of the liners, the other (brown) was missing

Smudges easily. Doesn't stay at all.

Easy to apply. Smudges.